When competing calendars, fragmented audiences and commercial pressures begin to affect the people who sustain the art world.
Having just returned from Art Mumbai, I have been thinking about the state of the art fair ecosystem and where it is headed. As a gallery, participating in a fair involves a considerable investment of time, money and effort. There is the preparation, the logistics, the transportation of works, the installation, the travel and the expectation that the fair will bring artists and galleries in front of an audience that matters. This year, the experience left me with some questions that I believe need to be addressed.
Art Mumbai ran from 12 to 15 November. At the same time, Mumbai was hosting two other significant events. The AD Design Show and AJIO Luxe Wkend both ran from 13 to 15 November.
The overlap was particularly relevant for the design community. Architects, interior designers, consultants and people working across art, design and luxury have traditionally been an important audience for Art Mumbai. This year, many of them chose to attend the other events. The AD Design Show, in particular, was drawing from a community that has considerable overlap with the audience an art fair would hope to attract.
There is nothing wrong with having multiple events in a city. Mumbai has the capacity to accommodate different platforms. The question is one of timing and consideration. When events with overlapping audiences take place simultaneously, they compete for the same people’s time and attention. In a market where the audience for contemporary art is still developing, this has consequences.
There was another factor at play. India Art Fair’s EDI+IONS initiative, with editions in Hyderabad and Ahmedabad, has been taking art into regional markets. I welcome the idea of developing audiences beyond the established centres. Ahmedabad hosted its edition in September, while Hyderabad had an earlier edition. Yet, from our experience, these initiatives also had an effect on the buyer pool that traditionally travelled to Mumbai for Art Mumbai. Some of the collectors and patrons who would ordinarily make that journey had already engaged with these regional programmes.
Regional expansion is necessary, but it raises a question about how these initiatives are planned. Are we developing new audiences, or are we redistributing an existing one? There is a difference between growing an ecosystem and dividing an audience that has taken years to build.
The impact was felt on the ground. Walk in visitors were fewer than many galleries would have hoped for, and the numbers were insufficient for several galleries to recover the costs of participation. An art fair may last four days, but the financial commitment begins months in advance. Booth construction, transportation, accommodation, staffing, travel and logistics add up. For smaller and independent galleries, these are substantial investments.
Institutional and museum buyers provided much needed support to a few galleries. Their presence and acquisitions were encouraging, and for some, they helped make the participation worthwhile. Yet this also points to a larger concern. A fair’s commercial success should not depend on a small group of institutional buyers compensating for a weaker than expected visitor and collector turnout.
This brings me to a question that the art world needs to ask itself. What exactly are we measuring when we call an art fair successful?
Footfall, celebrity appearances, social media coverage and the number of participating galleries make for impressive statistics. They create visibility and give an event a certain profile. But what happens to the galleries after the fair closes? Did they meet the right collectors? Were meaningful conversations initiated? Did artists find new audiences? Were sales sufficient to justify the investment?
These questions rarely receive the same attention as the spectacle surrounding the event.
The problem is larger than Art Mumbai or any single fair. We are seeing organisations within the art and design ecosystem expand their own programmes, compete for audiences and pursue their individual commercial interests. Each initiative may make sense on its own, but the collective impact deserves greater consideration.
Art fairs, regional platforms, design events and cultural organisations are drawing from overlapping communities. Their audiences are not unlimited. The same collectors, architects, consultants, designers and patrons are being approached repeatedly, often within short periods. Without some degree of coordination, organisations risk exhausting the very audience they are trying to cultivate.
There is also a larger imbalance in who bears the cost when things do not work as expected. Fair organisers have their own operating models, while galleries carry the direct financial burden of participation. Galleries, in turn, invest in artists, their practices and their careers. When the economics become difficult, the consequences eventually reach the artists.
A gallery that struggles to recover its investment becomes more cautious. It may think twice before bringing new artists to a fair, investing in ambitious presentations or taking risks with unfamiliar practices. The artist loses an opportunity, and the ecosystem loses some of the very experimentation and diversity it claims to support.
This is where I believe organisations need to rethink their responsibilities. A fair cannot look at participating galleries simply as exhibitors who pay for booth space. They are partners in building its identity, attracting collectors and giving the event its artistic content. Their experience and commercial realities should matter.
The same applies to regional initiatives. Taking art to new cities is a worthwhile endeavour, but success should be measured by the audiences developed and the opportunities created, not simply by the number of events organised. If an initiative draws from an existing pool without expanding it, the larger purpose needs to be examined.
I am all for competition. It encourages organisations to do better, think differently and create stronger platforms. But competition needs to coexist with a sense of responsibility. Organisations cannot keep expanding their individual footprints while overlooking the health of the ecosystem that sustains them.
The Indian contemporary art market has come a long way. Artists are finding new audiences, institutions are becoming more engaged and galleries are taking Indian art to international platforms. There is genuine work being done across the country. We should be building on this progress, not creating conditions that make it harder for the people doing the work to sustain themselves.
We need better planning, more coordination between organisations and a more honest conversation about the economics of participation. We need to look beyond attendance figures and impressive events and ask whether the people who make the art world possible are actually benefiting from its growth.
An art fair is ultimately a platform for art, artists, galleries and collectors. Everything else should support that purpose.
If the organisations that run these platforms forget this, we will eventually be left with bigger events, more elaborate presentations and a weaker ecosystem.
And that is a price the art world cannot afford to pay.